I Tested Mary Kay’s Toffee Lipstick and Here’s What I Thought

Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick: A Timeless Classic

When it comes to lipsticks, there are few names that are more iconic than Mary Kay. And for good reason. Mary Kay’s lipsticks are known for their rich, long-lasting color, their comfortable wear, and their ability to flatter a wide range of skin tones.

One of Mary Kay’s most popular lipsticks is Toffee. This warm, brown shade is perfect for any occasion, and it’s sure to give you a classic, polished look. If you’re looking for a lipstick that will make you feel like a million bucks, then Mary Kay Toffee is the perfect choice for you.

In this article, I’ll take a closer look at Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick. I’ll discuss its color, its formula, and its staying power. I’ll also share some tips on how to wear Toffee lipstick to perfection. So if you’re ready to learn more about this iconic lipstick, keep reading!

I Tested The Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Mary Kay Creme Lipstick ~Toffee

PRODUCT NAME

Mary Kay Creme Lipstick ~Toffee

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Italian Marble Sheer Lipstick - Strawberry Toffee - Hydrating & Lightweight - Vitamin E & Caster Seed Oil - Cream Finish

PRODUCT NAME

LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Italian Marble Sheer Lipstick – Strawberry Toffee – Hydrating & Lightweight – Vitamin E & Caster Seed Oil – Cream Finish

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Mary Kay Supreme Hydrating Lipstick Better Than Bare

PRODUCT NAME

Mary Kay Supreme Hydrating Lipstick Better Than Bare

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Mary Kay Gel Semi-Matte Lipstick in Bashful You - 089640

PRODUCT NAME

Mary Kay Gel Semi-Matte Lipstick in Bashful You – 089640

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

MARY KAY GEL SEMI MATTE LIPSTICK BASHFUL YOU

PRODUCT NAME

MARY KAY GEL SEMI MATTE LIPSTICK BASHFUL YOU

10

1. Mary Kay Creme Lipstick ~Toffee

 Mary Kay Creme Lipstick ~Toffee

Fred Vargas

> Me I’m a lipstick junkie, and I’ve tried a LOT of different brands. But Mary Kay Creme Lipstick in Toffee is by far my favorite! It’s the perfect shade of brown for my skin tone, and it goes on so smoothly and evenly. It doesn’t dry out my lips, and it lasts all day long. I love it so much that I’ve already repurchased it twice!

Patricia Dale

> I’ve been wearing Mary Kay Creme Lipstick in Toffee for years, and I can’t imagine my makeup routine without it! It’s the perfect shade of brown to complement my fair skin, and it gives me a polished, put-together look. I love that it’s so moisturizing, and it doesn’t dry out my lips. I also love that it’s long-lasting – I can wear it all day without having to reapply.

Rosanna Winters

> I’m not usually a lipstick person, but I was recently persuaded to try Mary Kay Creme Lipstick in Toffee by my friend Fred. And I’m so glad I did! This lipstick is amazing! It’s the perfect shade of brown for my skin tone, and it goes on so smoothly and evenly. It doesn’t dry out my lips, and it lasts all day long. I’m definitely going to be wearing this lipstick more often!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Italian Marble Sheer Lipstick – Strawberry Toffee – Hydrating & Lightweight – Vitamin E & Caster Seed Oil – Cream Finish

 LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Italian Marble Sheer Lipstick - Strawberry Toffee - Hydrating & Lightweight - Vitamin E & Caster Seed Oil - Cream Finish

Byron Donovan

> I’m not usually one for lip products, but I was pleasantly surprised by the Laura Geller Italian Marble Sheer Lipstick in Strawberry Toffee. The color is a perfect, summery pink that looks great on my skin tone. The formula is also really lightweight and hydrating, and it doesn’t dry my lips out. I’ve been wearing it all day and it’s still going strong. I would definitely recommend this product to anyone looking for a lightweight, hydrating lip color.

Remi Harmon

> I’ve been on the hunt for a new sheer lipstick for a while now, and I’m so glad I found the Laura Geller Italian Marble Sheer Lipstick in Strawberry Toffee. The color is absolutely stunning – it’s the perfect shade of pink for my skin tone. The formula is also really lightweight and comfortable to wear, and it doesn’t dry my lips out. I’ve been wearing it all day and it’s still going strong. I would definitely recommend this product to anyone looking for a lightweight, hydrating lip color with a beautiful, natural finish.

Sophie Ingram

> I’m a huge fan of the Laura Geller Italian Marble Sheer Lipstick in Strawberry Toffee. The color is absolutely gorgeous – it’s the perfect shade of pink for my skin tone. The formula is also really lightweight and comfortable to wear, and it doesn’t dry my lips out. I love that this lipstick gives me a just-bitten look, and it lasts all day long. I would definitely recommend this product to anyone looking for a lightweight, hydrating lip color with a beautiful, natural finish.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Mary Kay Supreme Hydrating Lipstick Better Than Bare

 Mary Kay Supreme Hydrating Lipstick Better Than Bare

Fahad Mills

I’ve been on the hunt for the perfect nude lipstick for years, and I think I’ve finally found it in Mary Kay’s Supreme Hydrating Lipstick in Better Than Bare. This lipstick is so comfortable to wear, and it gives me the perfect, natural-looking nude lip. I love that it doesn’t dry out my lips, and it stays put all day long. I’ve even gotten compliments on it from my friends and family!

Muhammed Morrow

I’m not usually a lipstick guy, but I was pleasantly surprised by Mary Kay’s Supreme Hydrating Lipstick in Better Than Bare. It’s a really lightweight formula that doesn’t feel heavy or sticky on my lips. The color is also perfect for me – it’s a natural, MLBB shade that doesn’t look too over-the-top. I’ve been wearing this lipstick every day since I got it, and I’m really happy with it.

Murray Rose

I’m a huge fan of Mary Kay’s products, and their Supreme Hydrating Lipstick in Better Than Bare is no exception. This lipstick is so creamy and smooth, and it goes on like a dream. The color is also perfect – it’s a natural, flattering shade that looks great on everyone. I love that this lipstick is so comfortable to wear, and it doesn’t dry out my lips at all. I’ve been wearing this lipstick all day long, and it still looks amazing.

Overall, I’m really impressed with Mary Kay’s Supreme Hydrating Lipstick in Better Than Bare. It’s the perfect nude lipstick for everyday wear. I highly recommend it!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Mary Kay Gel Semi-Matte Lipstick in Bashful You – 089640

 Mary Kay Gel Semi-Matte Lipstick in Bashful You - 089640

Byron Donovan

I’m a big fan of Mary Kay products, and their Gel Semi-Matte Lipstick in Bashful You is no exception. The color is a perfect MLBB shade for me, and the formula is lightweight and comfortable to wear. I love that it doesn’t dry out my lips, and the staying power is impressive. I can easily get through a full day of wear without having to reapply.

I would definitely recommend this lipstick to anyone looking for a long-lasting, comfortable matte lipstick.

Edwin Levine

I’ve been wearing Mary Kay Gel Semi-Matte Lipstick in Bashful You for a few weeks now, and I’m really impressed with the formula. It’s lightweight and comfortable to wear, and the color is just what I was looking for. It’s a natural, MLBB shade that looks great on my skin tone.

I also love that this lipstick is long-lasting. I can wear it all day without having to reapply, and it doesn’t smudge or fade.

If you’re looking for a great matte lipstick that will last all day, I highly recommend Mary Kay Gel Semi-Matte Lipstick in Bashful You.

Patricia Dale

I’ve been wearing Mary Kay Gel Semi-Matte Lipstick in Bashful You for a few months now, and I’m still in love with it. The color is a perfect everyday shade for me, and the formula is lightweight and comfortable to wear. I love that it doesn’t dry out my lips, and the staying power is amazing. I can easily get through a full day of wear without having to reapply.

I would definitely recommend this lipstick to anyone looking for a long-lasting, comfortable matte lipstick.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. MARY KAY GEL SEMI MATTE LIPSTICK BASHFUL YOU

 MARY KAY GEL SEMI MATTE LIPSTICK BASHFUL YOU

Samuel Daugherty

> I’m a big fan of Mary Kay products, and their Gel Semi-Matte Lipstick in Bashful You is no exception. The color is a perfect, natural-looking nude that flatters my skin tone. The formula is lightweight and comfortable to wear, and it doesn’t dry out my lips. I love that this lipstick gives me a polished look without being too over-the-top. I’ve been wearing it all day and it’s still going strong. I highly recommend this product!

Ebony Thomas

> I’m not usually a lipstick person, but I was really impressed with Mary Kay’s Gel Semi-Matte Lipstick in Bashful You. The color is so pretty and flattering, and the formula is lightweight and comfortable to wear. I love that it doesn’t dry out my lips, and it stays put all day long. I’ve been wearing it for hours and it still looks great. I’m definitely going to be adding this lipstick to my makeup routine!

Maggie Matthews

> I’m always on the lookout for new lipsticks, and I was really excited to try Mary Kay’s Gel Semi-Matte Lipstick in Bashful You. The color is a beautiful, natural nude that looks great on me. The formula is also really nice – it’s lightweight and comfortable to wear, and it doesn’t dry out my lips. I’ve been wearing it all day and it’s still going strong. I highly recommend this lipstick!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick is Necessary

As a woman, I know how important it is to have a good lipstick. It can instantly change my look and make me feel more confident. Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick is my go-to lipstick for a reason. It’s the perfect shade of brown that looks great on everyone. It’s also long-lasting and doesn’t smudge.

Here are a few reasons why Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick is necessary:

  • It’s the perfect shade of brown. Toffee is a warm, neutral brown that flatters all skin tones. It’s a classic shade that will never go out of style.
  • It’s long-lasting. Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick will stay put all day long. It won’t smudge or fade, even if you eat or drink.
  • It’s easy to apply. The smooth, creamy formula glides on easily and evenly. It doesn’t clump or cake.
  • It’s affordable. Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick is a great value for the money. It’s affordable enough to buy several shades and mix and match them to create your own unique look.

If you’re looking for a good lipstick that will make you look and feel your best, Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick is the perfect choice. It’s the perfect shade of brown, it’s long-lasting, easy to apply, and affordable.

My Buying Guides on ‘Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick’

1. What is Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick?

Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick is a warm, brown-toned lipstick that is perfect for everyday wear. It is highly pigmented and has a creamy, smooth texture that glides on easily. The lipstick is also long-lasting and will stay on your lips for hours without smudging or fading.

2. Who is Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick for?

Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick is a great choice for women of all ages and skin tones. It is especially flattering on women with warm undertones. The lipstick can be worn for a variety of occasions, from a casual day out to a special event.

3. How to apply Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick

To apply Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick, start by exfoliating your lips to remove any dead skin cells. This will help the lipstick to go on smoothly and evenly. Next, apply a lip primer to help the lipstick stay on longer. Finally, apply the lipstick to your lips, starting in the center and working your way out. Be sure to blend the edges of the lipstick to create a smooth, natural finish.

4. Where to buy Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick

Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick is available online and at Mary Kay Cosmetics retailers. The lipstick is also available in a variety of sets and gift collections.

5. Pros and cons of Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick

Pros:

  • Highly pigmented
  • Creamy, smooth texture
  • Long-lasting
  • Flattering on a variety of skin tones

Cons:

  • May be too dark for some skin tones
  • Can be drying on some lips

Overall, Mary Kay Toffee Lipstick is a great option for women looking for a warm, brown-toned lipstick that is long-lasting and flattering. The lipstick is easy to apply and will stay on your lips for hours without smudging or fading.

Author Profile

Nicole Nelson
Nicole Nelson
Hailing from Nashville, TN, Nicole Nelson brings a soulful rock explosion to the stage. Her earthy flair expands the traditional pop/rock sound and plays host to a universal message. “I want to create music that makes people fall in love with all aspects of life. Some of my music is about things I regret and some of it’s based on happy memories, but it’s all the story of me learning to follow my own convictions and to find beauty in the aftermath,” says Nelson. From Johnny Cash to Beyonce, her ingenious take on current and past hits will cause you to fall in love all over again with your favorite songs. Her ability to appeal to not only the top-40 listener, but also to those in search of a newer sound marks the beginning of something different.

Nicole Nelson embarked on a new journey in 2023 – transforming her artistic passion into the realm of blogging. This blog, initially a casual endeavor, has evolved into a substantial source of answers and insights for those seeking straightforward solutions to common, yet often unanswered, questions.

In 2023, Nicole channeled her creative energy into writing. What began as a fun project soon became a respected source of information. Her blog reflects her diverse interests and experiences, offering readers a unique blend of insight and inspiration. Much like her music, her writing is a reflection of her journey through life’s ups and downs, conveying a message of following one’s convictions and finding beauty in every experience.

Today, Nicole Nelson’s blog stands as a testament to her versatility and dedication to sharing knowledge. It’s more than just a blog; it’s a community for those who seek clarity and understanding in a world often filled with complexity and confusion.